Skip to content
News

GTA 6 reviews: 99 on Metacritic and OpenCritic, the scores and the flaws

Confirmed Published on 11 min read By Alex di LeonidaGuide Last checked
Launch Trailer frame: Jason, in a U.S. Army Marauder Combat Training School t-shirt, leaning on a red sports car next to Lucia in a denim jacket, in front of stacked shipping containers
Jason and Lucia at a container yard: his t-shirt reads U.S. Army, the past his official bio describes. Image: Rockstar Games

GTA 6 reviews went live on Wednesday, November 18 at 12:00 Italian time, the day before launch, and the verdict is close to unanimous: 99 on Metacritic and 99 on OpenCritic, without a single mixed or negative review. Below are the scores from the main outlets, Italian and international, the flaws that come up in several reviews, how many hours it takes according to those who finished it, and how it runs on PS5, PS5 Pro and Xbox.

The PS5 page for Grand Theft Auto VI on Metacritic: Metascore 99, Universal Acclaim, Must-Play badge, user score tbd, and below it the breakdown with 150 positive reviews, 0 mixed and 0 negative

The PS5 page at 23:17 CET on November 18: the score box says 150 reviews, while the full list on the same page already counts 156, because Metacritic updates its counters at different moments. Screenshot from Metacritic.

When the reviews came out

The embargo lifted on November 18 at 12:00 Italian time (11:00 in the UK, 3:00 AM on the US West Coast). Rockstar never announced it: Insider Gaming reported the time on November 17, and the publishing times of the reviews confirm it, with VGC going live at 11:00 UK time and Shacknews at 3:00 AM Pacific. How we got there, through rumors and denials, is in our news on when the reviews would land.

The first wave is almost entirely on PS5 and PS5 Pro: Xbox reviews are few, which is why the Xbox page on Metacritic has 14 scores against more than 150 on PS5.

A 99 that ties a record

The 99 did not move all day. The press tracked it as reviews piled up: 99 from 100 reviews according to Insider Gaming in the first hours, then 99 from 144, from 147 and from 153 as more came in. The lowest score visible on Metacritic is ScreenHub’s 80, an Australian arts and culture outlet: for the aggregator even an 80 counts as a positive review.

The OpenCritic header for Grand Theft Auto VI: Mighty badge, Top Critic Average 99, 99% of critics recommending it and the first scores, from IGN 10 out of 10 to DualShockers 10 out of 10, with the link to all 88 reviews

OpenCritic at 23:17 CET on November 18: “Mighty” is the site’s highest tier, and the player rating stays hidden until it reaches 20 ratings. Screenshot from OpenCritic.

Scores from Italian outlets

OutletReviewerScoreNotes
Multiplayer.itPierpaolo Greco10Played on PS5 Pro, plus about ten hours on a base PS5
Everyeye.itGiuseppe Arace10Mentions some technical compromises on base PS5
Spaziogames10100 on Metacritic; notes the 30 fps and a download over 200 GB
IGN ItaliaAlessandro Digioia9.5The only score below 10 in this table
MondoXboxGiuseppe Genga10Reviewed on Xbox Series X|S
UagnaLorenzo Bologna10
GamesurfClaudio Magistrelli10Score reported by ItaliaTopGames

The review with the most practical detail is Multiplayer.it’s: 76 hours to finish every story and optional mission, with the completion counter stuck at 70.3%, a story in five chapters, English-only voice acting and highly configurable Italian subtitles (languages and text are covered in our guide to GTA 6 in Italian). Readers are a little cooler: their average is 8.3 from 141 votes.

Scores from international outlets

OutletReviewerScore
IGNLuke Reilly10/10
GameSpotTamoor Hussain10/10
EurogamerChris Tapsell5/5
Game InformerMatt Miller10/10
Edge100 on Metacritic
VGCJordan Middler5/5
Push SquareSammy Barker10/10
GamesRadar+Josh West5/5
Giant BombDan Ryckert5/5
The GuardianKeza MacDonald100 on Metacritic
Washington PostGene Park100 on Metacritic
PolygonGiovanni Colantoniounscored

More perfect scores come from Easy Allies, Hardcore Gamer, DualShockers, Shacknews, GameRant, PlayStation Universe, GamingBolt, GameSpew, COGconnected, Cultured Vultures, GAMINGbible, IGN Spain, IGN Germany, Hobby Consolas and Areajugones.

Few outlets went below a 10, among them: GAMES.CH 98%, GameStar 97, Game8 96/100, Wccftech 9.6, Worth Playing 9.5, GRY-Online 9.5, and 9 out of 10 from TheSixthAxis, PlayStation LifeStyle, Noisy Pixel, Gfinity and ZTGD (the only one of this group on Xbox Series X). The New York Times does not give scores: the 90 shown next to its name on Metacritic is the aggregator’s conversion, not the paper’s verdict.

The lines that sum up the tone: for IGN, GTA 6 is “exquisitely detailed, endlessly ripe for experimentation, and uncompromisingly engineered”; for VGC “a modern masterpiece”; for The Washington Post “an astonishing American epic”.

What almost everyone likes

The reviews keep coming back to the same points:

  • Leonida: density, detail, pedestrians with lives of their own.
  • Jason and Lucia: the couple and their love story; for The Verge it is the most mature GTA Rockstar has ever made. The Jason and Lucia pages collect what is known about the two.
  • Wanted level and police: witnesses, cameras, clothes and vehicle all matter, as TechRadar describes. The system is explained in our wanted level guide.
  • Heists you plan, praised by Push Square and Shacknews.
  • Radio and soundtrack.

The flaws that keep coming up

No review treats them as serious, but some recur:

  • 30 fps with no performance mode, not even on PS5 Pro: flagged by Multiplayer.it (“a missed opportunity”), Push Square, TechRadar and Spaziogames.
  • Pacing: for Push Square the story drags in its final stretch; for GameSpot (reported by Forbes Australia) progression requirements break up the story; for Worth Playing the opening chapters are slow.
  • Missions too guided: Game Informer and Multiplayer.it say so, the latter calling the mission design still rigid. The Guardian mentions missions that fail without a clear reason.
  • Combat: clumsy for The Verge, which also finds the weapon wheel frustrating; Push Square takes issue with “bullet sponge” enemies in the endgame and overly stiff adaptive triggers.
  • Details: for IGN the motorbikes handle more stiffly than before and completed missions cannot be replayed from the list (according to The National). Ars Technica finds the “wokeness” jokes stale, the action repetitive at times and Jason less successful than Lucia. Multiplayer.it notes less geographic variety than other Rockstar worlds.

How long GTA 6 is, according to reviews

On the story alone reviewers agree: about 60 hours, according to VGC and Push Square. Before launch, estimates of 50 and of 80 hours were going around. Push Square, with more than 150 hours played, puts it at about 80 hours with side activities and over 300 for 100%, depending on how much you lean on guides. Multiplayer.it, as noted, stopped at 76 hours with 70.3% and estimates “well over a hundred hours” to see almost everything.

The hours played before writing give a sense of scale: over 150 for Push Square, over 100 for Shacknews, around 100 for TechRadar, 90 to reach the ending for Wccftech.

How it runs on PS5, PS5 Pro and Xbox

As for bugs, there are few. Shacknews, playing on PS5 Pro, had no crashes and its only bug was a coffee cup floating in mid-air (the flying sofa that looked like a bug was tied to a tree); among its annoyances are the GPS, which while you are wanted shows no route until you lose the police, and Jason and Lucia wearing masks, sunglasses and hats the player never picked. The Verge saw a few minor bugs; Push Square and VGC report nothing significant. The first update already arrived on November 13, as covered in our news on patch 1.002.

And on the stock market

The game launches on November 19 on PS5 and Xbox Series X|S: date, unlock times and preload are in our release guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is GTA 6’s Metacritic score?

99 on PS5, from more than 150 reviews that are all positive, and 99 on Xbox Series X from 14 reviews (checked on November 18 around 23:15 CET). On OpenCritic the Top Critic Average is 99, with 99% of critics recommending it.

Is GTA 6 the highest-rated game ever?

According to Forbes and Vice its 99 ties the record of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, from 1998, but with many more reviews. For Rockstar it is the highest score ever, above GTA IV’s 98.

How long is GTA 6?

About 60 hours for the story alone according to VGC and Push Square, about 80 with side activities and over 300 for 100%, according to Push Square.

Does GTA 6 have a 60 fps mode on PS5 Pro?

No. Reviews confirm 30 fps on every console, PS5 Pro included. The Pro offers a cleaner image, ray-traced shadows and a steadier frame rate.

What scores did Italian outlets give?

10 from Multiplayer.it, Everyeye.it, Spaziogames, MondoXbox, Uagna and Gamesurf; 9.5 from IGN Italia.

In short

  • Reviews went live on November 18 at 12:00 Italian time, one day before launch.
  • Metacritic 99 on PS5 (more than 150 reviews, zero mixed or negative) and on Xbox Series X; OpenCritic 99, with 99% of critics recommending it.
  • It ties Ocarina of Time’s record and beats GTA IV’s 98, Rockstar’s previous best.
  • Strengths: Leonida, Jason and Lucia, the wanted system. Flaws: 30 fps even on PS5 Pro, pacing, guided missions, combat.
  • The story runs about 60 hours; 100% takes more than 300.

New guides, as soon as they drop.

An occasional email with the good stuff: verified news, new guides, and new points on the map. Zero spam.

No spam, one-click unsubscribe. Your email is never shared. Privacy